My conclusion was that I needed yet another new icon for the Droid version. Looking at their suggestions, they specifically do not want a cut-off object in the icon, so I went back to the full ‘A.’ They didn’t want subtle gradients and shading so those were gone. To give the icon a unique shape, I made the blue background a smaller square than the rest of the elements, so the femur and calipers stick out from the top and bottom, using transparent areas:

As I’ve said before, a lot has changed since 2004. Icons nowadays are even fancier and the old Anthropomotron icon was barely acceptable even for that time. I decided that I would take another stab at making the Anthropomotron icon.

Apple has written icon design guidelines for iOS apps (and one for Mac icons).They’re a fascinating read for those interested in graphic design. They emphasize a sort of shiny realism: realistic elements but simplified. I’ve also liked the generic Mac app icon, which also has an ‘A,’ with a ruler as the crossbar. One of the things i didn’t like about the old Anthropomotron icon was that it didn’t look definitively like an ‘A.’ It kind of looks like an ‘R.’ For the new icon I decided to add a clearer crossbar, adding a ruler to the picture. I drew the concept and scanned it into Illustrator:

I was happy that my drawing skills have improved since 2003. But, there are a few problems. While the proportions are realistic, the legs of the ‘A’ are very thin. If the entire ‘A’ is visible, the shapes become ambiguously small.

Also, I’m used to the comic art style, which has black outlines defining the shapes. That’s not realistic. I tried to solve these two issues by removing the outlines in Photoshop and zooming in the image so the ruler is along the bottom edge of the image:

I thought this was better, but it’s still missing something. It seemed to lose a lot of its ‘A’-ness in this alignment. A little frustrated, I grudgingly went to bed. After a few minutes of laying there, I bolted out of bed, fired up Photoshop again, and did this:

Tilting everything worked! I saved that, and slept like a baby. The next day I worked towards making the final draft of the icon. I made the blue and yellow match the actual colors in the app. Then I added some textures to the three elements (wood, metal, and actual femur texture), and some gradients and shading for depth. This is the final Anthropomotron icon for iOS:

Next: a step backwards for the Android icon!

Also, I keep portraits and other pictures featuring just people behind a privacy barrier. You can see them if you’re a Flickr buddy of mine.